The Inner Monologue

Thinking Out Loud

Alright—let’s do a sober, numbers-y “what if” for a median U.S. family if trade wars actually crater Chinese manufacturing and decouple supply chains.

I’ll keep it simple and explicit about assumptions so you can understand them.

Baseline assumptions (so we’re on the same page)

  • Median U.S. household pretax income “today”: ~$80k (round number).
  • Spending mix: ~70% services, ~30% goods. China dominates a big slice of goods (electronics, apparel, furniture, toys, tools, many car parts, solar gear, e-bikes, etc.).
  • Shock: China output/exports collapse for several years; U.S. replaces supply with domestic/near-shore (Mexico, Vietnam, India) at higher cost + capacity constraints.
  • Policy: Fed fights inflation (rates stay higher for longer); government throws money at reshoring.

Headline results (my best central estimate)

  • Years 0–3: Real pain. CPI runs +3–5 percentage points above baseline for 2–3 years; unemployment +1–2 pp; mortgage/auto rates stay elevated.
    Median family: real after-tax purchasing power down ~6–10%; out-of-pocket spending up $5k–$9k/year versus baseline.
  • Years 3–10: Supply diversifies; automation/near-shoring scale up. Inflation cools, wages catch up some.
    Median family: real income gap narrows to ~–1% to –3% vs pre-shock trend (call it $1.5k–$2.5k/year worse than the world-with-China).
  • Years 10–20: New equilibrium. Higher domestic capital stock, more resilient supply, somewhat higher structural prices but better middle-skill wages in tradable sectors.
    Median family: ends up ~+2% to +5% above pre-shock trend in real income if the reshoring/jobs/automation flywheel actually spins. If it sputters, expect flat.

Where the pain shows up (first 3 years)

Approximate price bumps relative to “normal”:

  • Electronics/phones/computers: +20–40% initially; availability issues.
  • Appliances/furniture/tools/toys: +10–25%.
  • Clothing/footwear: +8–15%.
  • Cars/parts, tires, EV batteries: +10–20%; longer waits; repair parts delays.
  • Solar, inverters, e-bikes, power tools: +20–40%; home energy upgrades slip.
  • Groceries: indirect +1–3% from packaging/equipment inputs.
  • Services: pressure from higher goods costs + wages; +1–3% spillover.
  • Mortgage/auto rates: stay higher; refinancing relief delayed.

A typical median family budget sees ~$400–$750 more per month for 24–36 months, mostly from durable goods, car costs, and higher financing rates.

Jobs & wages

  • Short run: layoffs in retail/logistics tied to missing inventory; factory hiring ramps but starts slow; unemployment +1–2 pp. Wage growth lags inflation → real wage dip.
  • Medium run: manufacturing/automation, construction, energy equipment, and logistics hiring offset losses; wage growth improves—especially for technicians, electricians, machinists, CDL drivers, and industrial maintenance.
  • Long run: tradable-sector pay premia modestly higher; more apprenticeship/credential pathways; better job security vs single-country dependency.

Housing & wealth

  • Home prices: mixed. Rates suppress demand; materials/labor costs hold up prices for new builds. Net: sideways to slightly down near term, then resume trend.
  • Mortgages: many households stay “rate-locked.” Fewer moves, tight inventory.
  • Stocks: near-term volatility (retail/consumer electronics down; industrial automation, rail, ports, Mexican/Indian suppliers up). 20-yr outlook fine if supply chains re-root successfully.
  • 401k/529: short dip, then track broader productivity path.

Two scenarios to bracket the 20-year outcome

A) Messy decoupling (worse case): Coordination fails, litigation/controls whipsaw, and capacity builds too slowly.

  • 0–3 yrs: –10 to –15% real income hit; shortages.
  • 3–10 yrs: lingering –3 to –5% vs trend.
  • 10–20 yrs: roughly flat to +2%.
  • Lived reality: tighter budgets, delayed big purchases, slower energy transition.

B) Managed transition (my central case): Aggressive but coherent policy; fasttrack permits; immigration for skilled trades; tax credits for capex; Mexico/India/Vietnam scale up.

  • 0–3 yrs: –6 to –10% real hit.
  • 3–10 yrs: –1 to –3%.
  • 10–20 yrs: +2 to +5%.
  • Lived reality: rough 2–3 years, then decent wage gains and more resilient supply.

What changes in daily life

  • You keep phones/laptops/appliances longer; repair culture grows.
  • More Made in USA/Nearby labels—higher sticker prices, better parts availability over time.
  • More waitlists for cars and certain electronics.
  • Trades become hot: kids get pitched mechatronics instead of MBAs.
  • Home energy upgrades slower/ pricier at first; domestic solar/storage takes a few years to scale.

Ballpark family budget example (year 1–2 shock)

  • Electronics/appliances refresh deferred but when purchased: +$800–$1,500/year (averaged).
  • Auto (purchase/repairs/tires/insurance effects): +$900–$1,600/year.
  • Clothing/household goods: +$400–$800/year.
  • Interest (car loan/CC carry, not mortgage if fixed): +$300–$900/year.
  • Services pass-through: +$300–$700/year.
    Total: +$2,700 to $5,500/year (lean case) up to +$9k (if you hit a car + fridge + laptop in the same year).

Wildcards that move the needle

  • Semiconductors: If U.S./ally fabs ramp faster than expected, electronics pain eases a lot.
  • Energy prices: If oil/gas stay calm, it softens everything. A spike makes it worse.
  • Policy execution: Permitting, grid upgrades, and workforce training are kingmakers.
  • Allied capacity: How fast Mexico/India/Vietnam scale, and how smooth the logistics.

What a median family can do about it

  • Lock a fixed-rate mortgage if moving; otherwise don’t chase refi until rates truly fall.
  • Stagger big purchases; buy durable, repairable models; grab critical spares (phone batteries, tires, filters).
  • Consider used/refurb electronics; extend warranties only on high-failure items.
  • Upskill toward trades/automation/QA/logistics—or encourage kids that way.
  • Invest (prudently) in reshoring beneficiaries (industrial automation, power equipment, rail/ports, North American suppliers) rather than consumer importers.

Published by

Leave a comment